Skip to Content
Top
Insurance Bad Faith Handling Complex Cases With Unparalleled Expertise

Bad Faith Insurance Attorneys In Columbus

Did Your Insurance Company Wrongfully Deny Your Claim?

When an individual is injured in an accident, they often need medical attention, physical therapy, and other treatments that can be very costly. Thankfully, most people have insurance that helps cover these costs. Insurance is designed to help people pay for medical expenses they haven't planned for or weren't prepared for.

Unfortunately, many insurance companies fail to honor the contract they have with individuals when accidents occur. Their main goal is to save as much money as possible, and they will do everything they can to minimize costs. This means that some insurance company will even commit "bad faith" acts against their own clients.

In most cases, these companies have the best legal coverage their dollars can buy. When an injury victim tries to claim the compensation they paid for in their contract, insurance companies slam them with delays, denials, and other tactics to avoid paying.

At Rourke & Blumenthal, we put our combined 150 years of experience to work for our clients who are dealing with bad faith insurance cases. We know the ins and out of insurance law, and we work hard to build a strong case on our clients' behalf. When you hire our personal injury firm, you can rest assured that our Columbus bad faith insurance lawyers will provide the counsel and representation you need.

Let Us Handle Your Claim

Our firm has been AV Preeminent® Rated by Martindale-Hubbell®, our lawyers have been selected for Best Lawyers in America® and included in the Super Lawyers® list, and we are members of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum®. With our results, reputation, skill, and compassion, we always do everything we can to secure the compensation our clients deserve.

We can investigate your contract and your claim to determine if your insurance company has acted in bad faith. Our legal team puts together strong cases that demonstrate when an insurer has breached the covenant of good faith and fair dealing with our clients. We aim to help our clients recover general damages, any losses involved, punitive damages, and attorney fees, as we work on a contingency fee basis. This means that our Columbus bad faith insurance attorneys only get paid if we recover money damages on your behalf.


If you have been treated in bad faith by your insurance company, it is time to take action. Contact our firm today at (614) 321-3212 to find out if we can build a case on your behalf.


A Proven Track Record of Success

  • $8,500,000 Verdict for Amputation Injury
  • $7,400,000 Accident Causing Amputation
  • $6,500,000 Wrongful Deaths Caused By Arson
  • Record-Setting $6,000,000 Rourke & Blumenthal Achieves $6 Million Settlement
  • $5,300,000 Paralysis

We Come Highly Recommended

Learn what our happy clients have to say about working with our team
    "You NEED attorneys who are experienced in TBI cases."
    Wonderful firm! We have worked with other attorneys in the past and Mike and Tim blew us away. If you have a brain injury in the State of Ohio, you NEED attorneys who are experienced in TBI cases, not just motor vehicle accidents or other personal injury matters. It makes a huge difference having an attorney who understands the medical, emotional, and financial issues a family suffers after a TBI. They are professional, compassionate, and great communicators. I would recommend this office to anyone.
    - Suzanne
    "Attorney Stoudt is the best lawyer I've ever worked with."
    Attorney Jon Stoudt is the best lawyer I've ever worked with. He did everything he could to help me. From the start, Jon was very responsive and always explained everything in terms I could easily understand. Jon's staff was also kind and responsive. I highly recommend Jon and would use him again in the future. Several months after being done with my case, another lawyer, handling a different part of the case, commented on how well Jon handled my civil suit.
    - Jillian
    "Mr. Rourke and his team were extremely compassionate, knowledgeable and friendly"
    From the very beginning and to the very end of a long process, Mr. Rourke and his team were extremely compassionate, knowledgeable and friendly. I found them to be honest and easy to communicate with, day or night, weekday or weekend. Mr. Rourke was always professional but at the same time made you feel important and took as much time that was needed to explain the many steps in this process. Everyone of his team were very respectful and caring of everyone in my family involved in our case. I will have an admiration for Mr. Rourke and his team for the remainder of my life.
    - Kelly
    "Excellent Counsel"
    Jonathan Stoudt gave us excellent counsel during our time with him.
    - Cathy
    "I always felt that he had my best interests as the top priority."
    Mr Timothy Mahler represented me after a personal injury auto accident. He was professional, knowledgeable, empathetic and experienced. I always felt that he had my best interests as the top priority. I was relieved from the intricate and time-consuming tasks related to the accident, free to focus on healing and recovery. He managed the complicated insurance and settlement to the best outcome. His team always treated me with respect. I would highly recommend Mr Mahler and his team. Thank you.
    - Cathy B.
    "I will forever be grateful for their help!"
    I suffered physical injuries and a concussion from an auto accident in December of 2020. The team, from receptionist to attorneys, were nothing less than stellar, professional, kind, and hard working. The accident and aftermath were extremely stressful; but the Rourkes, Michael Senior and Michael Junior, helped me navigate the process while I focused on healing. For me, recovery from the accident was the most important part of the process. While I worked on recovering, Rourke and Blumenthal worked on negotiating a fantastic settlement for me. I will forever be grateful for their help!
    - Maggie S.
    "These attorneys always do what they promise."
    Attys. Mike Rourke, Sr. and Mike Rourke, Jr., helped us understand and settle all the legalities after my husband was hit be a car while riding his bicycle. Their extensive knowledge with injury cases, and their professionalism were ever-present, along with their empathy and understanding of what people experience after injuries that change lives. These attorneys always do what they promise, and in a timely and concise manner.. We would recommend Rourke & Blumenthal for anyone who needs legal services related to an accident or injury.
    - Stefanie M.
    "Our family is so grateful to have Rob Miller represent my daughter’s personal injury case."
    Our family is so grateful to have Rob Miller represent my daughter’s personal injury case. He is extremely knowledgeable about Ohio Law and was very patient with my numerous questions. Rob was always genuinely concerned about my daughter’s recovery and well being first. He is professional, knowledgeable, understanding, patient and we are so pleased with the outcome of the settlement. I would highly recommend Rob Miller to anyone looking for a top personal injury attorney.
    - Kathy

What Sets Us Apart From The Rest?

Rourke & Blumenthal is here to help you get the results you need with a team you can trust.

  • Evening & Weekend Appointments - We Will Come to You
  • We Don't Get Paid Unless We Recover Money for You
  • We are Able to Handle Complex Cases that Other Lawyers Can't
  • Attorneys Who Have Been Included in Ohio Super Lawyers®
  • AV® Rated - Top Rating for Ethics and Legal Skill
  • Member of Million Dollar Advocates Forum®
Contact Us For Your Free Case Evaluation!

Whether you have questions or you’re ready to get started, our legal team is ready to help.

Or
Call Us Today (614) 321-3212
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy