Call Today For a Free Case Evaluation 614.321.3212
Meet Our Dedicated Attorneys Offering Over 75 Years of Combined Experience in Personal Injury Cases

Timothy M. Mahler

Timothy Mahler

Tim is a partner at Rourke and Blumenthal. He focuses his practice on civil litigation, including auto and trucking accidents, medical malpractice, product liability and catastrophic fire cases. Tim has obtained favorable results for clients in a wide variety of cases, including a settlement of $7.4 million where his client was struck by a front end loader in a work site accident; a settlement in excess of $4.8 million in a medical malpractice wrongful death case; a settlement of $6.5 million in premise liability arson case; and a settlement in excess of $4.5 million for a family injured in a propane gas explosion in their home. Tim has also been on the winning side of multiple jury verdicts in complicated medical malpractice cases where no settlement offer was made before trial. For more information, visit the Verdicts & Settlements page.

Tim was recently named one of central Ohio's Top Lawyers by Columbus CEO. He has been selected numerous times by his peers as an Ohio Rising Star by Ohio Super Lawyers, which places him among the top 2.5% of all attorneys in the State of Ohio age 40 and under or who have been practicing law 10 years or less. He graduated magna cum laude from Capital University Law School where he was on the Executive Board of the Capital University Law Review. In addition to his work on behalf of his clients, Tim has served as board member for the Ohio Association for Justice. He is an active member of the American Association of Justice, the Ohio Association of Justice, and has served as a guest lecturer for the Capital University Law School Trial Advocacy Program.


Juris Doctor

  • Capital University Law School, Columbus, Ohio, 2005
  • Honors: Magna Cum Laude
  • Honors: Order of the Curia
  • Law Review: Capital University Law Review, Executive Articles Editor

Bachelor of Arts

  • The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, 2002
  • Honors: Cum Laude

Areas of Practice

  • Civil Litigation

Professional Associations and Memberships

  • The American Association for Justice
  • Ohio Association of Justice
  • Ohio Bar Association
  • Columbus Bar Association

Contact Ohio personal injury lawyer Timothy M. Mahler today.

We Come Highly Recommended

See what our past clients have to say about their experience with our firm.
  • “Our family is very appreciative of the hard work that Timothy and his firm has done.”


  • “I would highly recommend this firm!”


  • “Mr. Rourke and his son are good people that are there to help when you need them.”


  • “Michael went above and beyond to get things done”


  • “Jon saved me over thirty thousand dollars when I didn't have a nickel to my name.”


  • “I would highly recommend Mike and his firm.”


  • “The expertise and knowledge they showed was outstanding.”


  • “Jonathan was very detailed and kept me updated continually.”


  • “I highly suggest Jon and if I were to ever get in an accident again, which I certainly hope I do not, I will contact him!”


  • “Knowledgeable and Experienced”


  • “Works hard for his client”

    Karl Frybarger

  • “His legal capacity presented me with a settlement that was congruent with our established goals”


  • “Jonathan made us feel he was genuinely involved with our lives throughout our ordeal”


  • “Jonathan was very detailed and kept me updated continually.”


  • “I will certainly consult his services again with the next legal matter I have.”