Skip to Content

Unraveling the Defective Product Claim Process


We rely on countless products for our daily needs and activities. However, not all products are created equal, and occasionally, defective ones slip through the cracks. When a product malfunctions, causing harm or injury, it is crucial to understand the concept of defective product claims.

Manufacturers and distributors have a legal duty to ensure the safety and reliability of their released products. If they fail in this duty and a consumer suffers harm, the injured party has the right to hold the at-fault party responsible for their actions. This accountability is essential for consumers and the companies involved, as it promotes product safety and consumer protection.

This blog post aims to provide readers with a comprehensive understanding of navigating a defective product case. We will explore the various aspects of such claims, empowering individuals to assert their rights and seek compensation for the injuries and losses they have suffered. Additionally, we’ll discuss the importance of having a personal injury lawyer assist throughout the process.

At Rourke and Blumenthal LLC, we deliver skilled and compassionate legal guidance in Columbus. Schedule a consultation by calling us at (614) 321-3212.

The Three Dimensions of Defects

Imagine using a product as intended, only to find yourself harmed due to a flaw. This unfortunate scenario underscores the essence of a defective product. Defective products refer to items that, despite being used as expected, cause harm to consumers due to flaws or deficiencies.

Product liability claims arise when individuals assert that their harm or injuries were caused specifically due to a particular type of defect within the product itself. These claims provide a legal pathway for seeking compensatory, punitive, or exemplary damages for various forms of harm, such as personal injury, death, or property loss.

The distinct types of defects that can lead to legal recourse include the following:

  • Design defects: Under the category of design defects are situations where the product's design harbored foreseeable risks that ultimately outweighed the benefits it offered. In such cases, a flaw in the product's design itself renders it unreasonably dangerous, even when manufactured and used correctly.
  • Manufacturing defects: Manufacturing defects arise when the construction of a product deviates from its intended design or formula. Even if a company exercises due care during the product's construction, it can still be deemed defective if a flaw emerges during manufacturing.
  • Instructions defects: Instructions defects arise when a manufacturer either knew or should have known about the potential harm that could result from using their product. In these cases, inadequate warnings or instructions were provided, leaving consumers unaware of the dangers associated with the product's use.

Gathering Crucial Evidence for Your Defective Product Claim

Evidence can help build a solid foundation for your claim. You can include various pieces of information to support your assertions.

Documenting the Defect and Harm

One of the first steps in bringing a defective product claim is to meticulously document the item itself and the defect that caused harm. This crucial documentation serves as a tangible record of the evidence supporting your claim.

Invaluable evidence that can establish the existence of the defect includes the following:

  • Photographs
  • Videos
  • Detailed descriptions highlighting the flaw

Collecting Purchase and Warranty Information

Gathering purchase and warranty information is also essential to building a strong case. These documents provide a timeline of your ownership, establishing your relationship with the product and the parties involved.

You can solidify your claim and reinforce the link between the defective product and your harm by providing the following:

  • Receipts
  • Invoices
  • Relevant warranty documentation

Gathering Medical Records and Bills

In cases where the defective product has caused personal injury, gathering comprehensive medical records and bills is imperative. These documents illustrate the extent of your injuries, the medical treatments received, and the associated expenses. Medical records testify to the physical and emotional toll of the defective product on your well-being, bolstering your compensation claim.

Identifying and Interviewing Witnesses

Witnesses may have observed the incident or possess relevant information about the defect or its consequences in certain situations. Identifying and interviewing these witnesses can significantly strengthen your case. Their firsthand accounts can provide credibility and additional perspectives to support your claim. Witness statements can serve as powerful testimony, helping to establish a clear narrative surrounding the defective product and its impact on your life.

Preserving the Product

Preserving the defective product itself holds immense significance in a defective product claim. The product is tangible evidence, enabling experts and investigators to assess its condition, design, or any potential manufacturing flaws.

Avoid modifying, repairing, or disposing of the product, as it may be crucial to establishing liability and proving the existence of the defect. By preserving the product in its original state, you safeguard an important piece of evidence that can strengthen your case.

Identifying Responsible Parties

Identifying the parties potentially responsible for the harm caused is crucial.

Those that may be liable include the following:

  • Manufacturers: The manufacturer bears a significant responsibility in ensuring the safety and quality of their products. If a defect in the product's design or manufacturing process is discovered, the manufacturer may be liable for the resulting harm. Uncovering the manufacturer's liability requires investigating their role in the production, design, and quality control processes, which may have contributed to the defect.
  • Suppliers: Suppliers can be held accountable for injuries caused by defective products. A supplier is any entity involved in placing the product on the market, including selling, distributing, packaging, labeling, installing, or repairing it.

Navigating the Negotiation Process for a Fair Settlement

Once you have filed a defective product claim, it is common for parties to engage in settlement negotiations as a means to resolve the dispute without going to trial. Understanding the settlement process is vital to reaching a mutually acceptable resolution. Settlement negotiations provide an opportunity to explore potential compromises and pursue fair compensation for the harm caused by the defective product.

Evaluating Settlement Proposals

You will likely receive settlement offers from the defendant or their insurance company during negotiation. Evaluating these offers requires a careful analysis of various factors. Consider the extent of your injuries, the impact on your quality of life, medical expenses, lost wages, and any other damages incurred.

Assessing the adequacy of the offer involves comparing it to the potential outcome of a trial, factoring in the risks, costs, and time associated with litigation. It is essential to seek legal counsel to help assess the fairness of the settlement offer and guide you in making an informed decision.

Negotiating with the Defendant's Insurance Company

The defendant's insurance company will often be involved in negotiations. These companies usually have teams of skilled adjusters and lawyers focused on minimizing the amount they have to pay in claims. Negotiating with the defendant's insurance company can be complex, requiring a thorough understanding of your case's legal and factual aspects. It is crucial to have an experienced attorney who can advocate for your rights and navigate the complexities of insurance negotiations on your behalf.

Taking Your Case to Trial

Sometimes a trial becomes necessary to pursue the desired outcome. The decision to proceed to trial may arise when a fair and reasonable settlement cannot be reached or when the circumstances warrant a complete examination of the evidence and legal arguments. When the stakes are high, and the pursuit of justice demands it, taking your case to trial is a courageous step toward holding the responsible party accountable.

The Power of Legal Assistance in Navigating Your Claim

The guidance of a seasoned personal injury lawyer is paramount. They possess the knowledge, experience, and resources to navigate the intricate legal landscape surrounding defective product claims.

Hiring a lawyer helps protect your rights and ensures that you have a strong advocate throughout the process. Their insights can empower you to make informed decisions, build a solid case, and pursue fair compensation for the harm you suffered.

To speak with one of our Columbus attorneys at Rourke and Blumenthal LLC, contact us at (614) 321-3212.

Share To: